Showing posts with label Builder. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Builder. Show all posts

Monday, May 29, 2023

RERA why the apathy?

THE REAL ESTATE (REGULATION AND DEVELOPMENT) ACT, 2016 is an act brought in to safe

guard the purchasers from being taken for a ride by the promoters. There were too many such instances around NCR which prompted the Central Government to bring in this law.

This law has been pronounced in 2016 and became a law in all the states with respective state promulgating their own Act. However, if one reads the main Act and the various state versions there is a certain amount of dilution by the state governments for the reasons best known to them.

To prevent money being misused it was mandated to set up Escrow accounts to keep the money in those accounts and only a part of the amount was allowed to be used by the promoter for construction based on certification by authorised persons like Chartered Engineer/Architect etc. This is one reason many a promoter is reluctant to Register his project with RERA.

RERA insists on submitting a list of products and makes/Brands that are proposed to be used in the construction and expects the promoter to use the same. However, what has been submitted by the promoter is not known to the buyers and the intended transparency is lost here.

One of the main criteria for qualifying for registration with respective state RERA is more than 8 flats or 500 Sq Mt land area on which development is taking place. Then how come most projects which fit into this norm are not registered with RERA. RERA though very powerful is understaffed. It is impossible to monitor development that is taking place in the entire state. What is more surprising is this body is under the aegis of the Ministry for Urban Development & Municipalities. Practically every building including an independent house is mandated to take planning permission from the Local body.

Under these circumstances why there is no integration between RERA & Respective local body, more so when both are under the same ministry. Every plan approval which qualifies for registration with RERA should be automatically shared to RERA by the local body. All guideline sheets issued to the promoter by the Local body should set a deadline for RERA registration in the guideline sheet and enforce it. 

Enforcement is much easier for a Local body as they mortgage 10% of the project size with themselves and no promoter can afford to lose the 10% of his project to the government. Occupation certificate which is given when the building is completed releases this 10%, but not having a RERA registration will compulsorily not make the promoter qualify for Occupation Certificate/No Objection Certificate/Completion Certificate (as they are called in different states)
.
As usual the consumer education is little or negligible. Is a buyer really concerned about what is good for him, this is a million dollar question and leaves one wondering, is our Nation full of compromisers. Here is an Act brought out in the interest of the consumer / Home Buyer and they hardly ask the promoter any question regarding RERA registration and or easily convinced by the reply of the promoter. As long as the projects are getting completed, buyer is relatively safe, Alas if there is any Hiccup he will find it difficult to deal with the promoter who would be mightier by size.

Consumer should be able to check about the projects RERA registration status just like how one checks their PNR. The moment an enquiry comes from a mobile phone a OTP should be sent out to the number which is seeking to know the status of the registration. Once the OTP is matched Project registration details as submitted by the promoter should be sent out to the prospective buyer including the GPS location of the project. Any misuse of the information by competitors could be made a punishable offence as a deterrent for misuse.

Banks do ask for RERA registration particulars to approve the project for Home loan sanction process. However, there is no such requirement prescribed for single file processing by the financial institution. 

RERA & Local Body should insist on prominent display of the RERA registration Number and the Plan Sanction Number of the local body at the project site. Any deviation from this should attract a substantial penalty. 

It is interesting to note the effectiveness of RERA seems to be quite strong in the states ruled by the BJP while few other states seem to be lagging in the implementation of the RERA Act in its entirety. One could visit the state RERA websites like Maharashtra, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh etc in comparison with states like Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Rajasthan the intent to help the consumer is absent in few states while the purpose of this Act is well demonstrated in other states.

Unless the State becomes a protector of the consumer ensuring there is no undue bias towards the wealthy promoters who could contribute to the party fund, consumer will never win.

It is important such an important Consumer centric Act is not diluted by vested interests, who are happy to make some money.  Once all projects get automatically reported to the RERA by the Local bodies, there will be drastic improvement in compliance. Let RERA not become a money spinner for few and be a protector of the consumer as was intended while bringing out the law.

Sunday, August 23, 2015

Persistence pays off

 While I wouldn’t call my self a good practitioner of what I am going to write about being persistent, it is a lesson that I have learnt over the years and had to rue many a hasty decision. It is very important that one pursues what they are confident of achieving.

In every business there are going to be hard times only those who are finding a way out within the business can have long term success. Many of us give up or start looking at greener pastures elsewhere, this inevitably leads us to look at greenfield businesses or something we are new for. I have a couple of case studies which i could share.

This is a story of two business people who are in real estate development business in Chennai. Around the same time both started putting up apartments in early 80's. One started with his brother and another with a set of partners. Both later became independent owners of their respective businesses after parting with their erstwhile partners.

Person 1, had a successful business in promoting residential apartment buildings, he was very much successful in the JV route and continued to build apartments each building having about 6-8 apartments mostly.

Person 2 also chose the JV route and started getting good offers and was into buildings with 10-20 apartments per building.

P1 continued to leave his brand on many buildings with his property owners getting him more JV partners due to timely delivery, with low inventory to sell, he was able to accomplish more finished projects and more goodwill.

P2 decided to go public and get his company listed, for this purpose he signed up few mega projects. He managed to get his public issue subscribed and he had money to develop the projects, he wanted. Unfortunately few bad apples upset his plans and his plans started going haywire. More over the property market went into a recession mode. Most of the big projects got struck with unsold inventory. Forcing P2 to start looking at other means to shore up his revenues.

Meanwhile P1 continued with his build small model and was able to whether the recession and was smiling all the way to the bank when most of his peers were struggling with unsold inventory.

What tells us here is persistence to the business and finding a niche can help the business person weather the short term bad times in the business, in this period if we start looking at other ways to ensure revenues or become too ambitious, then the result will be like the person 2.

Similarly there is another story of continuation which paid off in the case of one and how it affected the other in Liquor wholesale business in Bangalore.

Businessman 1 who was a first generation entrepreneur, managed to come close to the management of a Liquor concessionary in Bangalore and was able to get a good patronage, he built a house for himself and started seeing good cash flows.

Businessman 2 who was an employee in a liquor wholesale, took up an agency from the same concessionary and started establishing his business, he used to even accompany the consignments and ensure prompt delivery.

Suddenly the concessionary changed hands from one business house to another. Both the persons referred above were able to build bridges with the new concessionary and continued with their business. B1 was bit by a bug and wanted to start a steel re-rolling business, which looked very profitable at that point of time (Mid 90's). He went about establishing the same along with a technocrat. When the technocrat left in the midway, our man started focusing on this new venture more. Leaving the liquor wholesale to his trusted boys back at Bangalore. While B2 with focused approach was able to increase the volumes and was able to earn more profits. B1 with cash flows from liquor business getting diverted to the steel business naturally lost favour with the concessionary and was given less preference in terms of supplies.

B2 built a house, bought more properties established his brother in IT business. B1 languished with the jolt given by P Chidambaram as the FM to the steel re-rolling industry in the United front govt and lost both the liquor business and in steel business.

Both are real stories, which goes to show how one could flourish even in adverse situations if they stick to their core business and what will happen when we start thinking of riding two horses at a time.

While we could ape Dhirubhai or his son Mukesh in thinking about expansion or backward or froward integration, we have to remember, there has to be a scale to think and also one business which can give us the stable revenues to pursue the new businesses. This is more important in the case of Indian businesses, since our thinking is in terms of our kids running the show or ethical values being what they are, Only when systems and values and accountability rule the roost,

One has to be very careful about expansions and diversification's, it might be just good to stick to what you are good at.


(Copyright of the images used rests with the respective owners)